November 2005
 
Headlines

Seminar reports
New Publications
Whats New
Recent News

 

Seminar reports
 
Police Accountability: the Africa Region 14th and 15th October 2005
Organised by CHRI, Africa Office, Accra, Ghana
Julie Berg, Institute of Criminology, University of Cape Town.

On the 14th and 15th October the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI) facilitated a meeting in Accra, Ghana for the discussion of police accountability in the Commonwealth Africa region. The meeting was attended by representatives from a number of civil society groups and oversight bodies as well as police officials from Ghana and from a number of other Commonwealth countries including, Australia, India, Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, Sierra Leone, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda and the United Kingdom. The meeting consisted of presentations and discussions on the status of oversight in the Commonwealth Africa region and the challenges thereof, with country inputs from various oversight bodies and structures from South Africa, Nigeria, Uganda, Ghana, Tanzania and Kenya. A presentation was also made by the African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum or APCOF and by the Human Rights Unit of the Commonwealth Secretariat. Small group discussions on the process towards reform allowed participants to share various success stories of interaction between police and civil society groups in their countries. The meeting also facilitated the building of co-operation amongst the participants.
The meeting was specifically arranged so as to precede the Commonwealth Law Ministers Meeting held from the 17th to the 21st October, also in Accra and thus a concluding statement and recommendations was drafted and submitted to the Law Ministers to encourage continued debates on the topic of police accountability. The communiqué will also be submitted to those attending the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting in Malta in November.
On the evening of the 13th October the CHRI´s 2005 Report entitled Police Accountability: Too Important to Neglect, Too Urgent to Delay was launched at the British Council in Accra. The report is available at:
www.humanrightsinitiative.org

Challenges for Policing in the 21st Century: A Global Assessment
Elrena van der Spuy, Institute of Criminology, University of Cape Town
This recent conference organised by the International Police Executive Symposium - was held at the Police Academy of the Czech Republic in Prague, 4- 9 September 2005. The proceedings brought together more than 100 police practitioners and scholars from 40 countries and provided an opportunity to engage with both global dynamics and localised realities. In a globalised world order, security agencies confront increasingly similar demands – both internally and externally. Yet the structural diversity underlying the new global order was also apparent as speakers examined the ways in which local dynamics mould security agencies from Australia to Brazil, Japan to Lesotho, Pakistan to the USA, South Africa to Mexico. A wide range of themes were addressed in the nine plenary sessions: the shape and size of cooperation between policing agencies; the challenges of training and recruitment of police personnel; recent developments in the field of police oversight; the role of voluntarism and volunteers in policing; the role of police unionisation in the context of reform; the provision of security in the context of international peace-keeping in troubled zones and, the securitisation of policing policy in the post-9/11 environment. Supplies of Czech beer and local cuisine and a well planned cultural programme ensured that discussions continued outside of the formal setting of the conference. The city of Prague itself provided an imposing architectural setting for the deliberations. A selection of the papers will be published in Police Practice and Research: An International Journal. More details of (past and future) conferences can be viewed at http://www.ipes.info.

Back to top Top

 

New Publications
 
Independent Complaints Directorate Annual Report 2004/2005
The annual report of the ICD is available full text online.
Author: Independent Complaints Directorate
Published Date: 2005 View online>>>>

South African Police Service Station Monitoring Tool
The standardised monitoring tool and report back mechanism will be used when Parliamentary and Provincial Committees responsible for Safety and Security as well as individual members of parliament visit police stations. The purpose of this questionnaire is to facilitate effective oversight by the various parliamentary committees responsible for Safety and Security over policing at station level: provide these committees with useful independent data with which to make recommendations to improve the functioning of policing; compare successes and problems between stations and provinces; measure progress at police stations over time and to ensure more effective collaboration in oversight functions between the Portfolio Committee on Safety and Security of the National Assembly, the Select Committee on Security and Constitutional Affairs of the National Council of Provinces and the Standing Committees within the various provincial legislatures.
SAPSSTATIONMONITORINGQUESTIONNAIRE.doc (340 KB)
Author: Safety and Security Portfolio Committee
Published Date: 2005

Dirty Work of Democracy: A year on the streets with the SAPS
"What does it take to police South Africa’s streets? This is the question Antony Altbeker sets out to answer in The Dirty Work of Democracy, an account of the year he spent observing South Africa’s police officers in action across the country. The twelve months were spent with scores of officers working in police stations stretching from the foothills of the Maluti mountains in the old Transkei to the ganglands that surround the Mother City, from the oak-lined streets of Rosebank to the pot-holed tracks of Ivory Park. Murder, armed robbery, gangsterism and domestic violence: this is a fly-on-the-wall account of how street-level policing works and why it often doesn’t. It offers unique insight into the men and women behind the badge and into the world they confront every shift. Cops are loved and hated, praised and blamed, in equal measure. They experience our country as nobody else does, and see more pain and sadness in a day than many do in a lifetime. Altbeker takes us inside this unique and strange profession, and reports on it with both empathy and reflective distance".
Author: Antony Altbeker. The book is available from all major booksellers.
Published Date: 2005

Strengthening police oversight in South Africa
In 2002, the Open Society Foundation for South Africa (OSF-SA) and the Open Society Justice Initiative proposed a project to examine and strengthen police accountability in South Africa. From the outset, the project attempted to involve the full array of organisations and personnel whose work impinges on police oversight and accountability. An intensive consultative process brought together non-governmental organisations and experts as well as government stakeholders and personnel of police accountability bodies in South Africa. Arising out of this process, the project developed a dual focus on, firstly, strengthening state mechanisms for police oversight and, secondly, bolstering civil society’s own capacity to play a significant role in ensuring that such oversight worked effectively. This report presents the results of the projects and describes the process through which they were produced and presents the project´s main findings on the current state of policing oversight in South African today. Policingreport_screen.pdf (479 KB)
Author: Open Society Foundation for South Africa & Open Society Justice Initiative
Published Date: 2005

Security governance in South Africa
"This article provides a broad overview of the roles played by the various actors in the governance of the security sector, including the executive, parliament and civil society. It examines the main policy frameworks and touches on organisational transformation, because it is impossible to deal with governance in isolation from these issues. Policy processes and the frameworks they give rise to - in particular - are critical for effective governance. This article deals with the defence, safety and security and intelligence fields. A comprehensive overview would need to include the governance of criminal justice and foreign policy. The article does not seek to make an overall evaluation of governance, but to identify achievements, shortfalls and challenges".
Author: Gavin Cawthra. African Security Review 14 (3):95-106
Published Date: 2005
View Online>>>>

ISS Oral Submission to the Commission of Inquiry Into the Mandate and Location of the Directorate of Special Operations (Khampepe Commission)
The twenty page oral submission submission to the Khampepe Commission of inquiry into the mandate and location of the Directorate of Special Operations is divided into five sections. These are - The rationale for the establishment of the DSO; issues relating to the mandate of the DSO, especially in relation to that of the SAPS; the question of the oversight of the DSO; public perceptions regarding the DSO and the impact a change of institutional home would have on these; and the practical implications of a possible incorporation of the DSO into the SAPS.
Author: Institute for Security Studies
Published Date: 2005
View Online>>>>
Back to top Top

 

Whats New
 

New webpages for Angola and Namibia

Julie Berg has developed organograms showing policing oversight in Angola and Namibia. The webpages for these countries can be found by using the drop down menu on the top right hand side of the www.policeaccountability.co.za home page under "Select a region". Please let us have feedback on the organograms and send in any publications that promote democratic policing in Angola and Namibia.

Back to top Top

 

Recent News
 

Safety and Security Portfolio Committee. Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority
Parliamentary Monitoring Group.
www.pmg.org.za . 04/11/2005.
The Committee heard a briefing from the Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority. The briefing focussed on the functions of the Regulator in relation to the private security industry. All private security companies were required to be registered and comply with rules and regulations. Companies that did not comply with regulations had to pay fines, those that were found to have breached the law were handed over to the South African Police Services.
View details>>>>

Safety and Security Portfolio Committee. Independent Complaints Directorate Annual Report briefing continued. Parliamentary Monitoring Group. www.pmg.org.za . 02/11/2005.
The Independent Complaints Directorate continued its briefing on its Annual Report focusing on the Information Management and Research programme and the ICD budget. View details>>>>

Safety and Security Portfolio Committee. Launch of SA Police Service Station Monitoring Tool. 08/11/2005.
The SA Police Service Station Monitoring Tool was launched in Parliament today, the 8th November 2005. The Deputy Minister, Chairperson of the Portfolio Committee and a number of members of parliament were present, as well as the media and other interested parties. The standardised monitoring tool and reportback mechanism is to be used when Parliamentary and Provincial Committees responsible for Safety and Security as well as individual members of parliament visit police stations. View details>>>>

City defends police action against ANC protesters.
A´eysha Kassiem. Cape Times. 08/11/2005.
The City Council has said it supports police chief Bongani Jonas´s decision to deploy police to intervene in a protest on Sunday - a protest Cosatu says was a "political matter". Spokesman Sputnik Ratau yesterday echoed Jonas´s sentiments, saying the reason City Police had been sent to oversee the demonstration outside the Gugulethu Sports Complex - where the ANC provincial general council meeting was held - was because the protesters were on council property. View details>>>>

Safety and Security Portfolio Committee. ICD Annual Report briefing.
PARLIAMENTARY MONITORING GROUP. www.pmg.org.za . 26/10/2005.
The Independent Complaints Directorate’s newly appointed Executive Director, Mr Leslie Xinwa, led the presentation. The ICD faced a number of challenges, mostly related to the fact that it was understaffed. Members were particularly concerned about the number of vacancies in the organisation, especially since it claimed that a shortage of staff was its main challenge. Related issues such as dismissals, and disciplinary action were also raised. View details >>>>

Woman allegedly raped by police in jail.
Janine Stephen. The Star. Available online www.iol.co.za . 27/10/2005.
For two years, a woman held in a cell was allegedly raped repeatedly by three police officers - but only one officer has been hauled into the dock to answer the allegations. View details >>>>

Obstacle course to trim fat off the police.
Lee Rondganger. The Star. Available online: www.iol.co.za 27/10/2005.
Unfit and overweight police officers have been told to shape up or ship out. In three months´ time they must be able to complete a gruelling survivor-style obstacle course within 210 seconds. If they fail, they will be saddled with a desk job. View details >>>>

Death in police custody down nine percent.
SAPA.
Available online www.iol.co.za . 26/10/2005.
The number of deaths in police custody has declined by nine percent in the 2004/05 financial year, the Independent Complaints Directorate (ICD) told parliament on Wednesday. But delivering the ninth annual report to Parliament´s safety and security portfolio committee, acting director Leslie Xinwa reported no significant improvement in ICD performance.
View details>>>>

Victimised woman sues police for R1,2m.
SAPA. Available online www.iol.co.za . 18/10/2005.
The duty of the police to protect citizens in cases of family violence is expected to come under the spotlight this week in the Pretoria High Court. A Brakpan contractor and his wife are claiming R1.239m from the minister of safety and security after alleging police failed in their duty to ensure the safety of their family. View details >>>>

SA Police Services: National Secretariat for Safety and Security Annual Reports: Briefings .
Safety and Security Portfolio Committee
. Parliamentary Monitoring Group. 12/10/2005.
The South African Police Services (SAPS) briefed the Committee on its 2004/2005 annual report. The SAPS stated that overall the police had made many improvements from the previous year and were making a big effort to further improve in the next fiscal year. Most of their targets had been met and it was felt that the police were doing a good job with the resources they had. View details >>>>

Selebi vows to keep tabs on police ´slackers´.
Sheena Adams. Cape Argus. www.iol.co.za . 13/10/2005.
A vehicle tracking system expected to put an end to police officers going "AWOL" is one of a number of innovations being introduced by national police commissioner Jackie Selebi to improve police performance. View details >>>>


Scorpions: Problems ´inevitable´. Institute for Security Studies submission.
www.news24.com 07/10/2005.
Problems between the Scorpions and police were among the inevitable challenges of managing a society´s law enforcement, the Institute of Security Studies said on Friday. In a submission to the Khampepe Commission, it said: "Relocating the directorate of special operations (DSO) into the police does not eliminate the problem, it simply shifts the responsibility for dealing with it."
View details >>>>

When cops are crooks: Nearly 3 000 SAPS members guilty of crimes in two years.
Sue Segar. The Witness
. 07/10/2005.
How do we know whether the police officer tasked with protecting us from crime is also not a criminal? This was the question posed by the Freedom Front Plus, following alarming figures released by the Safety and Security Ministry. View details >>>>

Independent Complaints Directorate battles with backlog of complaints against police
Shaun Benton. Bua News.
28/09/2005.
Complaints against the police - numbering 5 790 in the past financial year - are still too high for the Independent Complaints Directorate to deal with, while trying to reduce a backlog of complaints inherited from previous years, the directorate said in its annual report tabled in parliament.
View details >>>>

South African to lead Interpol.
AFROL NEWS. 08/10/2005.
Delegates at the Interpol General Assembly have elected Jackie Selebi, National Commissioner of the South African Police Service and the first African ever, as the global police organisation´s new President. Mr Selebi pledged to lift the Caribbean and Africa on Interpol´s agenda during his upcoming leadership term. View details >>>>

SADC cross border operation trainees ready to participate in Operation Rachel.
http://www.info.gov.za . Joseph Ngobeni. 30/09/2005.
The Southern African Development Community (SADC) today boasted with twenty-six (26) successfully trained police members after completing a month-long training course in cross border firearm related and firearm destruction operations. These members will leave on 2 October 2005 for Mozambique to participate in a follow-up Operation Rachel exercise to gain hands on experience. View details >>>>

Zimbabwe:

Zim cops arrest activists.
www.news24.com . 08/11/2005.
Harare - Police in Zimbabwe have picked up at least two trade union activists ahead of planned protest marches set for Tuesday, the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) claimed in a statement.
View details >>>>

Mugabe´s police and vendors in running battles.
Michael Hartnack.
Cape Times. 07/10/2005.
Harare: Police armed with batons and riot shields fought running battles with street traders this week in a clampdown in the capital´s southern townships, news reports said yesterday.
View details>>>>

Nigeria:

DRC-NIGERIA: 11 policemen suspended over sex abuse allegations in DR Congo.
IRIN NEWS.
www.irinnews.org 27/09/2005.
Nigeria has suspended 11 policemen, including a senior officer, suspected of sexual abuse while serving as UN peacekeepers in the Democratic Republic of Congo. View details >>>>
Back to top Top

Subscribe    /    Unsubscribe    /    Change Details    /    Visit our Site
If you have any contributions, feel free to mail them to police@easimail.co.za for inclusion

© Police Accountability 2005. All Rights Reserved. Newsletter by Easimail

Please note that if your PC is not connected to the Internet while you're reading this e-mail, you may not be able to see some of the images. If you experience any problems with this newsletter or have any comments, please email info@easimail.co.za